EDIT: It turns out Deluge is looking specifically for an all lowercase extension ".torrent"
The torrent files I was testing today were of type ".TORRENT" which Deluge did not care about. I will be looking into the github project to see if I can make this a little less strict.
Settings:
Snapshot of the directory:
Snapshot of logs:
I am currently downloading a large torrent right now and it is all working. I have verified that my core.conf file has the autoadd_enable setting set to true. What else can I check? The autoadds were working last night. My router was reset this morning, but that is the only thing I can think of. I have also rebooted my device multiple times with no change in behavior. I have also tried multiple trackers.